The Two Envelopes Problem
One envelope holds twice as much money as the other. The arithmetic says swap — then says swap back, forever.
1953 (Littlewood, crediting Schrödinger), 1989 (envelope form)19 min read
English analysis
1885 – 1977
Cambridge analyst, and for thirty-five years G. H. Hardy's collaborator on the distribution of primes, Waring's problem and Fourier analysis. His 1953 collection "A Mathematician's Miscellany" preserves, in a few lines, a card version of the exchange paradox that he credits to Erwin Schrödinger — one of the earliest records of the two envelopes argument.
One envelope holds twice as much money as the other. The arithmetic says swap — then says swap back, forever.
1953 (Littlewood, crediting Schrödinger), 1989 (envelope form)19 min read
You add ten balls and remove one, infinitely many times. At the end, the vase is empty. What happened to all the balls?
19887 min read